Something Different Special Edition: Sorry Neil time to go

Dundee lost 4-0 to Rangers this afternoon to make it played 6 lost 6 drawn 0 for 2 against 14 . Neil McCann must go, no giving him the Hibs game next week or the Hamilton game the week after, go now. Only Dave Smith, Ivano Bonetti and Alan Kernaghan have worst records, defeat next week will see McCann slip to second worst and 6 straight defeats will be the worst start to a season since the 1920’s.

Neil McCann, when he was a Dundee player, was one of the better ones that I have seen but he is by far the worst manager, maybe not statistically yet, but as far as I am concerned he is. He will always have respect for his playing days with the club and the help he gave during the defiant season but history can play no part in the decision that now has to be made. Something has to be done now and an experienced manager brought in before we are down before Christmas. McCanns signing overall have been poor to say the least. Jack Hamilton has had a poor start, Genseric Kusunga is never a defender in a million years, Sofien Moussa up there with Colin Harris as being pretty much a rubbish striker, the list is actually too long to type up.

Dundee FC are in serious trouble, Neil McCann and his assistant have made it worse. The board have made bad appointment after bad appointment, time to get rid of this one and have a serious go and making a decent appointment. I would even be happy to put money into buckets to get Neil McCann gone as manager of the Dees. Always be well regarded as a player, but Neil that is now at risk also, time to go.



  1. Ricky

    Today’s result should be taken with a pinch of salt , Its not Rangers and Celtic you need points off its all teams around you . I watched the game today , The first half you were all right , battled hard and played some good stuff , second half a Rangers stepped up a bit a basically dominated . Dundee this season like Motherwell last season have had a horrendous start , but unlike Motherwell you’ve been unlucky , you should have beat St Mirren and St Johnstone , plus drawn with Aberdeen . You’ve been decent for huge spells , played good stuff battled hard , but the rub of the green just isn’t happening . One result will kick start a run .

    • Bruce Hosie

      I saw most of it and thought we were pretty dire to be honest. Dundee do play pretty football at times but it’s in the middle and isn’t effective. We can’t defend and can’t score. Some of MCCanns signings have been dire and this sticking to playing from the back means everyone knows how to play Dundee. The signing of Miller was a total shocker. No McCann has to go, lose next week and he will officially be the worst Dundee Manager ever but to be honest the fans have turned and have had enough, he has to be gone Monday.

      Thanks for commenting.

  2. Bruce Hosie


    At least St Mirren acted quickly, McCann should never have gotten the job in the first place. He has made me hate football some weekends and has got to go ASAP before the fans do.

    Thanks for commenting.

    • Bruce Hosie

      I would even Rennie with Carmichael as his assistant. Carmichael tells more believable stories than McCann.

      Thanks for commenting.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.