Robertson Doesn’t Get It

There will be a lot made of George Robertson’s words in New York this week regarding Scotland potentially leaving the United Kingdom; in Robertson’s words this would have a cataclysmic effect on the western world.

Many will write and blog about what he said and the words he used but for me this is again about stature, vanity and fear. People like Robertson, another failed Labour Politician in my opinion, just fear their personal loss of their self-elevated sense of importance. This is not about what is best for the country where they were born, well most of us regard Scotland as a country, but it is becoming increasingly clear that people like Robertson, Curran, Lamont, Cameron etc view Scotland as a region.

This speech is about Britain’s perceived place in the world, how certain people view Britain and themselves within it. Britain is no longer powerful, it is tolerated, Britain is not a military power, and it just happens to have obsolete nuclear weapons which it thinks gives it power. The simple fact is Britain is over, no matter what happens in September the days of Britain are over. We are a failed broke Union drowning in class and a perceived history that benefitted the few at a far too high cost to the many.

This debate, as we have all noted, is about the country we want to live in. Many of us will be very happy to live in an independent Scotland that puts its people and social justice first, that doesn’t want to dictate to the world, go to war with the world, a Scotland confident to stand on its own two feet and not sit at the feet of Germany and America. Robertson doesn’t get it, this is about the men and women, the children in our country, and it’s about creating the best opportunities for them. Society and Government should be about caring for and creating opportunities for everyone not the minority. Scotland is waking up to the fact that the people are no longer here to sweep and clean the houses of the Robertson’s of the world and to be thankful to be allowed to do it.

Robertson doesn’t get that whatever happens in September his days, and the days of his kind are slowly coming to an end in Scotland. They laugh at places like Iceland, but what they fear are places like Iceland where the people actually dictate what happens in their country not a elite supported by an unelected elite built around class.

The other thing that bothered me about Robertson’s speech was he went to America to implore the American Government to speak out against Independence. He made a mistake; the American Government are not the American people. I lived there briefly and what I found was a hard working, honest, caring nation of people, similar to our own, who will welcome Scotland with open arms and whose views in the main are not represented by their Government. Robertson does not get it.



  1. pa_broon74

    Not sure an explanation will be forth-coming.

    Establishment types fear examples of good practice from places like Iceland and Norway. Robertson is just daft enough to be a stalking horse for them, they’re terrified they get slung out on their backsides, sidelined, forever barred from the corridors of sway.

    Good riddance if you ask me.

    • Anonymous


      It just all gets boring but has to be challenged as these people see it as their right to rule over us. The fact he came across as an idiot just made it easier for us to rip into his opinion.

      Thanks for commenting.


  2. Not Not Daniel Coleman

    The only issue I have with this your baldness is, why do we want to be like other countries like iceland etc when we can simply be Scotland and do what is best for us. Maybe things in Iceland are alright, if you enjoy striking because £9 an hour isn’t enough then yes it’s brilliant there. I agree they have done well, especially after the mess they had. But I don’t think Scotland needs to follow other countries. The issues there are different, we can do what is right for us post-yes vote, not what worked in other countries as it is only to well known that one glove does not fit all.

    I agree, Iceland is good, but I think we can do better and be Scotland.

    I think we can work together to build Scotland, not Iceland or Norway 2.

    • Anonymous


      It’s not the case of wanting to be Iceland but to take a leaf out of their book with the protections they put in place for their people.

      Thanks for commenting.


  3. bjsalba

    Bloomberg reported on Iceland on January 27th this year as follows:-

    “Iceland let its banks fail in 2008 because they proved too big to save.

    Now, the island is finding crisis-management decisions made half a decade ago have put it on a trajectory that’s turned 2 percent unemployment into a realistic goal.

    While the euro area grapples with record joblessness, led by more than 25 percent in Greece and Spain, only about 4 percent of Iceland’s labor force is without work. Prime MinisterSigmundur D. Gunnlaugsson says even that’s too high.”

    Is that a disaster? Doesn’t sound like one to me.

    • Anonymous


      You are correct we can all learn from the Icelandic people and how they stood up for themselves.

      Thanks for commenting.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.